Contradiction

Refute against the claim

         Cathy says Charlie and the chocolate factory doesn't fit the defination of Cinderella story. However, I don't think so. The other 4 kids are all punished by Willy Wonka. We can guess, if they also pass the test then Charlie has no chioce to gain the factory. The other four kids certainly want to prevent anyone else to win the game, but they fail. Similarly, Cinderella's step mother and bad sister also want to prevent Cinderella, but they fail, too. The result is Cinderella goes to the party and meet the prince.

        The second point is in Charlie and chocolate factory Charilie don't have the prince or mate. The prince or the mate is a kind of person who can identify the beautiful characters from Cinderella. And Willy Wonka also has this ability to find good characters from Charlie. And mate gives Cinderella a happy life. Willy Wonka also gives Charlie a happy life.

        In a conclusion, Charlie and the Chocolate Factory is fit the defination of Cinderella story.